Posted on

Don’t Read This

One of the sections I always read in the Saturday editions of the Wall Street Journal always contain multiple book reviews. When a review sparks my interest as a potential source for a blog topic and future books, I usually purchase the book.

Well, there was a review on Meryl Frank’s new book in the Journal on 17 April 2023 (see below in the recommended reading section). It grabbed my attention because Ms. Frank, the former mayor of Highland Park, New Jersey, was entrusted by her elderly aunt with a thin book written to memorialize the murders of Jewish theater performers by the Nazis. Aunt Mollie turned the book over to Meryl with the instruction to keep the book safe and pass it on to her children.

However, Aunt Mollie made Meryl promise to never read the book.


Did You Know?

Did you know that Hitler and his generals made a lot of mistakes about the Allied invasion of Normandy? On the Allied side, Gen. Eisenhower was the “Supreme Commander-in-Chief” with defined lines of authority, but the Germans had a convoluted command structure. While Rommel was put in charge of the defenses, he reported to Field Marshal Gerd von Rundstedt (click here to read the blog, OB West) but neither Rommel nor Rundstedt had any power. The German navy, air force, and Schutzstaffel (SS) reported directly to Hitler.

Most of the key German commanders were absent from their posts at the time of the invasion on the morning of 6 June 1944. They were all in bed with their mistresses except for Rommel. He went back to Germany for his wife’s birthday.

Hitler went to bed late on 5 June and gave orders he was not to be awakened for any reason. He actually slept through the invasion. When he woke up and was told about the landings, Hitler believed this was a diversionary attack because he was convinced the primary invasion would take place at Pas de Calais. Therefore, he waited too long to dispatch his Panzer tanks to Normandy. The deception was due to the success of British counterintelligence being able to turn German spies into double agents with false invasion information fed to Berlin. Because the Allies had broken German codes, they knew senior command officers (as well as Hitler) were convinced the covert information was real. (Click here to read the blog, Double Cross System.)

The Germans believed any invasion would be delayed at that time because of bad weather in the North Sea and English Channel. However, Eisenhower gave the order to proceed with the invasion in the early morning of 6 June after his weather experts predicted a favorable break in the weather. The German weather-forecasting broke down and Hitler’s experts did not see the window of opportunity. (Click here to read the blog, The Historical Weather Forecast.)

Many of the German soldiers manning the coastal defenses were conscripts from Nazi-occupied countries. They did not want to die for the Nazis and gave up easily. The German Kriegsmarine, or navy was virtually absent in the English Channel. The largest wartime armada left England and crossed the channel unimpeded. The German Luftwaffe, or air force had lost control of the skies and its last remaining fighter squadrons in France had been moved too far away from the beaches to be effective.

Allied commanders 1945
Allied commanders immediately after the surrender of German forces in Reims, France. Gen. Eisenhower is holding the pens used to sign the instrument of unconditional surrender. Photo by anonymous (7 May 1945). PD-U.S. Government. Wikimedia Commons.

I guess winning a war ultimately boils down to the side that has the luckiest generals and makes the fewest mistakes.


Aunt Mollie 

By 1996, Mollie was in her mid-eighties. She was the sister of Meryl Frank’s mother and the family’s self-proclaimed “Memorial Candle.” In other words, Aunt Mollie was responsible for the remembrance of her family and ensuring the family stories were carried on to the next generation.

Meryl was the youngest of four sisters and named after her maternal grandmother. As Meryl grew up, Aunt Mollie’s stories introduced her to various family members including Meryl’s grandparents who emigrated to the United States in 1905 passing through Castle Garden, the precursor to Ellis Island. Meryl’s grandmother, Meryl Kagan, lived in Vilna, Lithuania until she married Michel and became Meryl Boyarsky. Read More Don’t Read This

Posted on

Desktop Murderer & British Agent

In May 1945, several senior Gestapo officials made their way to Dahme, Schleswig-Holstein (northern Germany on the Bay of Lübeck) to prevent their arrest by the Allies. Officials at the British Field Security Post in Lübeck learned about these men and their hiding place from a captured Gestapo man. Immediately, British military police drove 31 miles to the Strandhotel and arrested five former Gestapo men ⏤ two officers and three NCOs. Taken back to Lübeck, the prisoners were turned over for interrogation at the city’s Marstall prison.

Strandhotel in Dahme, Schleswig-Holstein
Strandhotel in Dahme, Schleswig-Holstein. Photo by Google Maps (date unknown).

One of those men was SS-Sturmbannführer and Kriminaldirektor, Horst Kopkow. At the time of his arrest, Kopkow was a relatively unknown Gestapo official but as time went on and the British interrogated former Gestapo men, Kopkow’s name kept being brought up. It turned out he was the department chief responsible for counterintelligence (i.e., arresting foreign agents), the German radio program known as “Funkspiel,” and well-regarded by his superiors for his knowledge of Soviet espionage.

Former Marstall Prison on the right
On the right is a section of the former Marstall prison. Photo by Heinrich Stürzl (1 June 2021). ©️ Heinrich Stürzl. PD-CC BY-SA 4.0 International. Wikimedia Commons.

After extensive official and unofficial investigations, it became clear that Kopkow was personally responsible for sanctioning the torture and ordering the executions of foreign agents of MI6 and the British-led Special Operations Executive (SOE). I’ve written before about Hitler’s “enablers” (click here to read the blog, Hitler’s Enablers – Part One – Wannsee Conference and here for Hitler’s Enablers – Part Two – The Camps). Kopkow was an enabler but as Stephen Tyas points out in his book (see below), the Gestapo chief was a “desktop murderer.” He never personally pulled the trigger or hanged a prisoner, but he signed the Sonder behandlung, or “Special treatment” orders from his Berlin desk. In the end, he escaped justice because of the protection provided by British Secret Intelligence Service (SIS), or MI6.


Did You Know?

Did you know that one individual was responsible for preparing France for the invasion of Normandy (i.e., D-Day)? During World War II, Jean-Louis Crémieux-Brilhac (1917−2015) served as Gen. de Gaulle’s propaganda chief. As the preparations for the Normandy invasion intensified during early 1944, M. Crémieux-Brilhac was assigned the responsibility for telling French citizens how to react once the inevitable invasion took place and efforts to liberate France began. He was secretary of the Free French Propaganda Committee, and he drew up four pages of instructions to “all French men and women not organized in, or attached to, a Resistance group.” Those instructions were handed over to the French service of the BBC. Separate orders were drawn up for broadcast to members of the Maquis. (These were the famous “personal” messages read out on the BBC in advance of the invasion ⏤ click here to read the blog, Dah-Dah-Dah-Duh.)

Crémieux-Brilhac’s messages were directed to the population in general as well as specific instructions to mayors, police, factory workers, etc. The biggest disagreement about the “call-to-arms” was between the Communists and the Gaullists. Communist resistance fighters were very influential in the French Resistance, and they demanded an all-out insurrection (i.e., general worker strikes and armed insurrection) on the eventual day of the invasion. M. Crémieux-Brilhac and the majority resisted the Communists’ demands and the majority won.

The instructions to the French were that “all French must consider themselves as engaged in the total war against the invader in order to liberate their homeland.” He made it clear that the French were to consider themselves “all soldiers under orders” and “Every Frenchman who is not, or not yet, a fighter must consider himself an auxiliary to the fighters.” Citizens living within the Normandy combat zone were instructed to “disrupt using all means transport, transmissions, and communications of the Germans.”

Jean-Louis Crémieux-Brilhac
Jean-Louis Crémieux-Brilhac. Photo by anonymous (date unknown).

After liberation, the original instruction documents were retained by M. Crémieux-Brilhac. Upon his death in 2015, the papers were donated to the French National Archives.


Let’s Meet Horst Kopkow 

Horst Kopkow (1910−1996) was born in East Prussia, Germany (now Poland) as the sixth child of a businessman and hotel owner. His childhood city, Allenstein, was overrun by the Russian army during the first world war and two of his older brothers died in the trenches on the French battlefields. These memories heavily influenced his vision of Russia and later, the Soviet Union with Kopkow vowing to fight Communism the rest of his life. Read More Desktop Murderer & British Agent