One of the sections I always read in the Saturday editions of the Wall Street Journal always contain multiple book reviews. When a review sparks my interest as a potential source for a blog topic and future books, I usually purchase the book.
Well, there was a review on Meryl Frank’s new book in the Journal on 17 April 2023 (see below in the recommended reading section). It grabbed my attention because Ms. Frank, the former mayor of Highland Park, New Jersey, was entrusted by her elderly aunt with a thin book written to memorialize the murders of Jewish theater performers by the Nazis. Aunt Mollie turned the book over to Meryl with the instruction to keep the book safe and pass it on to her children.
However, Aunt Mollie made Meryl promise to never read the book.
Did You Know?
Did you know that Hitler and his generals made a lot of mistakes about the Allied invasion of Normandy? On the Allied side, Gen. Eisenhower was the “Supreme Commander-in-Chief” with defined lines of authority, but the Germans had a convoluted command structure. While Rommel was put in charge of the defenses, he reported to Field Marshal Gerd von Rundstedt (click here to read the blog, OB West) but neither Rommel nor Rundstedt had any power. The German navy, air force, and Schutzstaffel (SS) reported directly to Hitler.
Most of the key German commanders were absent from their posts at the time of the invasion on the morning of 6 June 1944. They were all in bed with their mistresses except for Rommel. He went back to Germany for his wife’s birthday.
Hitler went to bed late on 5 June and gave orders he was not to be awakened for any reason. He actually slept through the invasion. When he woke up and was told about the landings, Hitler believed this was a diversionary attack because he was convinced the primary invasion would take place at Pas de Calais. Therefore, he waited too long to dispatch his Panzer tanks to Normandy. The deception was due to the success of British counterintelligence being able to turn German spies into double agents with false invasion information fed to Berlin. Because the Allies had broken German codes, they knew senior command officers (as well as Hitler) were convinced the covert information was real. (Click here to read the blog, Double Cross System.)
The Germans believed any invasion would be delayed at that time because of bad weather in the North Sea and English Channel. However, Eisenhower gave the order to proceed with the invasion in the early morning of 6 June after his weather experts predicted a favorable break in the weather. The German weather-forecasting broke down and Hitler’s experts did not see the window of opportunity. (Click here to read the blog, The Historical Weather Forecast.)
Many of the German soldiers manning the coastal defenses were conscripts from Nazi-occupied countries. They did not want to die for the Nazis and gave up easily. The German Kriegsmarine, or navy was virtually absent in the English Channel. The largest wartime armada left England and crossed the channel unimpeded. The German Luftwaffe, or air force had lost control of the skies and its last remaining fighter squadrons in France had been moved too far away from the beaches to be effective.
Allied commanders immediately after the surrender of German forces in Reims, France. Gen. Eisenhower is holding the pens used to sign the instrument of unconditional surrender. Photo by anonymous (7 May 1945). PD-U.S. Government. Wikimedia Commons.
I guess winning a war ultimately boils down to the side that has the luckiest generals and makes the fewest mistakes.
Aunt Mollie
By 1996, Mollie was in her mid-eighties. She was the sister of Meryl Frank’s mother and the family’s self-proclaimed “Memorial Candle.” In other words, Aunt Mollie was responsible for the remembrance of her family and ensuring the family stories were carried on to the next generation.
Meryl was the youngest of four sisters and named after her maternal grandmother. As Meryl grew up, Aunt Mollie’s stories introduced her to various family members including Meryl’s grandparents who emigrated to the United States in 1905 passing through Castle Garden, the precursor to Ellis Island. Meryl’s grandmother, Meryl Kagan, lived in Vilna, Lithuania until she married Michel and became Meryl Boyarsky. Read More Don’t Read This
Last year I wrote a blog about a Soviet all-female combat air regiment created to pilot rickety biplanes for the purpose of bombing German military targets after Hitler’s decision to invade the Soviet Union in June 1941. Die Nachthexen, or “Night Witches” were so feared by the Germans that any soldier or pilot who downed a Night Witch aircraft automatically earned the Iron Cross medal. (Click here to read the blog, The Night Witches.)
Today’s blog will focus on other Soviet fighters feared by the Germans. These were the Soviet women trained to be snipers and they were deadly. In fact, one of them was well-known to German soldiers. Her nickname was “Lady Death.”
Olha Tverdokhilbova, 98, at her home in Vinnytsia, Ukraine. A Soviet sniper during World War II, Olha recently offered her services as a skilled sharpshooter to the Ukrainian Resistance. Photo by Emanuele Satolli for The Wall Street Journal (May 2022).
Did You Know?
Did you know that many historians have pegged SS-Oberführer Oskar Dirlewanger (1895−1945) as the cruelest Nazi during the Third Reich? Considering the magnitude and depth of atrocities committed by the Schutzstaffel (SS) and others during the war, Dirlewanger must have been a particularly nasty individual with no conscience.
Joining the SS armed division, the Waffen-SS, Dirlewanger was given command of what became known as the “Dirlewanger Brigade.” One of his first assignments was as commandant of a labor camp. Investigated by the SS, he was accused of murder and corruption. Dirlewanger had young Jewish women injected with strychnine because he enjoyed watching them convulse to death. His leadership style encouraged drunkenness, looting, sadistic atrocities, rape, and murder. Himmler knew all about Dirlewanger but tolerated his behavior.
The Dirlewanger Brigade was assigned in 1942 to hunt down partisans in Belarus. His favorite tactic was to round up villagers and herd them into a barn. His men would set the barn on fire and anyone trying to escape was mowed down by bullets from machine guns. He used civilians to march over suspected mine fields. His men were encouraged to rape and torture young women while at the same time, employing Einsatzgruppen-style executions. During his time in Belarus, Dirlewanger was responsible for the deaths of 30,000 civilians and 14,000 alleged partisans. He was sent to Warsaw to assist in the suppression of the uprising. The brigade participated in the Wola massacre when 40,000 civilians were murdered. During that time, Dirlewanger ordered three hospitals to be burned. Patients died in the flames while Dirlewanger had the nurses gang raped and hanged along with the doctors. He was eventually assigned to Hungary and eastern Germany to try and halt the Red Army advancement. He was wounded and sent to the rear. In late April 1945, Dirlewanger went into hiding.
SS-Oberführer Oskar Dirlewanger. Photo by Anton Ahrens (c. 1944). Bundesarchiv, Bild 183-S73495/Anton Ahrens/CC-BY-SA 3.0. PD-CCA-Share Alike 3.0 Germany. Wikimedia Commons.
SS-Oberführer Dirlewanger was a psychopathic killer, “violently sadistic,” and an “expert in extermination and a devotee of sadism and necrophilia.” Even the most hardened Nazis thought his actions were too cruel. Arrested by the French in June 1945, Dirlewanger died in captivity a month later at the Detention Center Altshausen, likely at the hands of Polish interrogators.
Soviet Snipers
On 23 August 1939, Nazi Germany signed the German-Soviet Nonaggression Pact with Stalin. This gave Hitler the green light to invade Poland one week later and the world was plunged into war. Hitler broke the treaty on 22 June 1941 when his troops invaded the Soviet Union under Operation Barbarossa. At that point, Stalin was put on the defensive and forced to throw whatever he could at the rapidly advancing German army.
Unlike most western countries fighting Hitler, the Soviets were not squeamish about allowing women to join the men on the front lines. However, the women encountered male prejudice and ridicule while having to wear “hand-me-down” mens’ clothes. That all changed when the men saw the bravery, professionalism, and fighting ferocity displayed by the female soldiers and aviators.
Head of the Central Sniper School’s political department (i.e., commissar) talks to women leaving for the front. Photo by V. Krasutskiy (April 1943). PD-CCA-Share Alike 3.0 Unported. Wikimedia Commons.
One of the infantry units the Soviets formed after Operation Barbarossa was the 25th Rifle Division for the purpose of training and deploying snipers. In March 1942, the Central Women’s School of Sniper Training was established about nine miles outside Moscow. Recruitment requirements were that the women had to be 18 to 26, physically fit, and have at least seven years of education. Sniper trainees were taught to dig a foxhole, crawl on their stomachs, and determine wind speed, distance, and movement of a target. Most importantly, the sniper graduates could assemble and disassemble their rifles with eyes shut.
Red Army snipers assemble before heading to the front. Photo by anonymous (c. 1943).
Snipers exhibited similar characteristics: reticent, bordering on introverted, shy of publicity and focused on doing their job. They also possessed a great amount of patience and an innate cunning. Snipers were not expected to draw attention to themselves. Their survival depended on how well they could stay hidden. As the war progressed, the perception of snipers (particularly, the women) changed from being glorified riflemen to professional front-line specialists. Their status allowed them one day off each week⏤an unheard-of concession in the Soviet army. Women snipers accounted for more than 12,000 official German kills. In all, two thousand women became snipers for the Soviet Union⏤only about five hundred survived the war.
Using a helmet as a decoy, Soviet soldiers wait for German soldiers to fire and reveal their positions. Photo by anonymous (date unknown).
Most of the Soviet snipers always saved one bullet in their pistol for themselves. If a sniper was caught alive (man or woman), they were tortured to death by the Germans.
Lyudmila Pavlichenko’s J.P. Sauer 1913 pistol. One bullet was always saved. Photo by VoidWanderer (16 July 2018). World War II Museum in Kyiv. PD-CCA-Share Alike 4.0 International. Wikimedia Commons.Soviet Mosin-Nagant m/91-30 sniper rifle. Photo by anonymous (c. 2011). Mikkeli Infantry Museum. PD-CCA-Share Alike 3.0 Unported. Wikimedia Commons.
Lady Death
Lyudmila Mikhailovna Pavilichenko (1916−1974), or “Mila” as we will call her, was born in the Kiev Governorate in the Russian Empire. (Today, it is Kyiv, Ukraine.) She was always athletic and developed into an award-winning sharpshooter. By 1932, Mila had married and gave birth to a son. Unfortunately, the marriage fell apart and Mila returned home to her parents.
Soviet sniper Lyudmila Pavlichenko. Photo by anonymous (c. 1942-43). PD-Russian Public Domain. Wikimedia Commons.
In 1937, Mila enrolled in one of the sniper schools run by the Soviet army. When Germany invaded the Soviet Union, Mila was accepted into the army as a sniper and initially assigned to the 25th Rifle Division. During the early years, weapons (of any type or quality) were hard to come by including rifles. In August 1941, Mila obtained a Mosin-Nagant model 1891 bolt-action rifle and proceeded to kill her first two targets. After that, Mila began to kill the hated Fascists at a prolific rate. She has been credited with 309 confirmed kills during her active duty. (A confirmed kill is one that was witnessed by a second person.) It is likely that the real number is much higher.
Lyudmila Pavlichenko. Photo by anonymous (c. 1940s). Find a Grave. www.findagrave.com.
Mila was rapidly promoted and in 1941, she married a fellow sniper, Alexei Kitsenko. Her husband was killed shortly after the marriage and for the rest of her life, Mila never really recovered from the depression that accompanied losing Alexei. The 25th Rifle Division was sent to Sevastopol to fight the Germans during the siege of the city where Mila and other snipers accounted for more than one hundred kills during the battle. By May 1942, Lt. Pavlichenko was a legend in the Soviet army, and she became known as “Lady Death.”
Alexei Kitsenko and Mila. Photo by anonymous (date unknown). www.ww2gravestone.com.
Mila was badly injured at Sevastopol and Stalin ordered her to be evacuated. After recovering, Mila become a propagandist for the Soviets and traveled to many of the Allied countries including America where President Roosevelt invited her to the White House. Upon her return and for the remainder of the war, Mila trained snipers.
Lyudmila Pavlichenko (center) in Washington D.C. as a Soviet representative/delegate of the International Youth Assembly. Flanked by Justice Robert Jackson (left) and Eleanor Roosevelt (right), Pavlichenko was used by Stalin as part of his propaganda campaign. Photo by Jack Delano (September 1942). Library of Congress. PD-U.S. Government. Wikimedia Commons.Lyudmila Pavlichenko seated on the right. She is in Washington, D.C. as a Russian delegate representing the International Youth Assembly. Photo by Jack Delano (c. September 1942). Library of Congress. PD-U.S. Government. Wikimedia Commons.
“Dead Little Hitlers”
Roza Shanina (1924−1945) was the first female sniper to be awarded the Soviet “Order of Glory.” She was considered one of the top snipers in the Soviet army having killed fifty-nine German soldiers in a ten-month period. Three days after arriving at the front, Roza killed her first German. She described the situation:
“Finally, in the evening a German showed in the trench. I estimated the distance to the target was not over 400 meters (437 yards). A suitable distance. When the Fritz, keeping his head down, went toward the woods, I fired, but from the way he fell, I knew I had not killed him. For about an hour the fascist lay in the mud, not daring to move. Then he started crawling. I fired again and this time, did not miss.”
After only ten months on the Eastern front, 20-year-old Roza was found dead slumped over a wounded officer trying to protect him. Her chest had been blown open by a German mortar shell. Roza’s diary and letters were released in 1965 for publication and her contributions to fighting the Germans became well-known.
Roza Shanina with her sniper rifle. Photo by anonymous (date unknown). Za Rodinu/Flickr.Roza Shanina (left) teaches a man how to shoot. Neophyte snipers had an expected lifespan of two weeks on the front. Photo by anonymous (date unknown). Za Rodinu/Flickr.
The Russian Celebrity and Actress
Ziba Ganiyeva (1923−2010) was a Soviet celebrity and actress prior to World War II. She fought in the 3rd Moscow Communist Rifle Division as a sniper. Ziba crossed behind enemy lines sixteen times and is credited with twenty-one German soldiers killed during the Battle of Moscow. Ziba was seriously wounded and spent eleven months recuperating in a hospital. She was awarded the Orders of the Red Banner and the Red Star. After the war, Ziba went on to obtain her degree in philology.
Ziba Ganiyeva, celebrity and film actress (left) and as a Soviet sniper (right). Photo by anonymous (c. 1940s).Azerbaijani sniper Ziba Ganiyeva. She was credited with 21 kills. Photo by anonymous (c. 1942). PD-CCA-Share Alike 4.0 International. Wikimedia Commons.
“We Mowed Down Hitlerites Like Ripe Grain”
Nadezhda Kolesnikova (1921-unknown) volunteered in 1943 to serve as a sniper on the Volkhovsky Eastern Front. She was credited with nineteen kills and awarded the “For Courage” medal.
Nadezhad Kolesnikova (1921-unknown) volunteered on the Volkhovsky front and was credited with 19 kills. She was awarded the “For Courage” medal. Photo by anonymous (c. 1943). Media Drum World.
Lyuba Makarova was another top sniper. She participated in the support of the Third Shock army on the Kalinin Front in 1943. Sgt. Makarova killed 84 German soldiers and like Mila, she enjoyed shooting them in the stomach first before finishing off the job. She was awarded the “Order of Glory.”
Sgt. Lyuba Makarova. Photo by anonymous (date unknown). Media Drum World.Soviet sniper, Sgt. Lyuba Makarova (foreground) and other female snipers peer through their rifle scopes. This is likely taken during a training session. Makarova was credited with 84 kills. Photo by anonymous (date unknown).Yevgenia Makeeva was credited with 68 kills. Photo by anonymous (date unknown). Media Drum World.Nina Lobovskaya, commander of a company of female snipers who fought in the Battle of Berlin. Photo by anonymous (c. 1944).
Post-War
After the war, Mila became one of the most highly decorated women to serve in the Soviet army. She received the Order of Lenin twice and was designated a “Hero of the Soviet Union.” Mila finished her education and became a historian and author working for the Soviet navy. Eleanor Roosevelt visited Moscow in 1957 and made a point of visiting with Mila whom she had met during the war in Washington D.C.
Soviet Union, Great Patriotic War Excellence Badge for Excellent Sniper 1942. Photo by Fdutil (c. 2009). PD-Author release. Wikimedia Commons.Lyudmila Pavlichenko in Odessa. Photo by anonymous (c. 1971).
Largely due to the depression she suffered, Mila became an alcoholic and was burdened with post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD). These problems likely led to her early death at the age of fifty-eight. Her ashes are buried in the columbarium at Novodevichy Cemetery in Moscow with her son, Rostislav (1932−2007), buried next to her. After Mila’s death, a government ship was named after her as were streets and schools.
Mila’s final resting place in the columbarium. Photo by anonymous (date unknown). Find a Grave. www.findagrave.com.Burial plaque identifying Mila’s final resting place in the columbarium. Photo by anonymous (date unknown). Find a Grave. www.findagrave.com.
Soviet Photographs
Stalin used his female soldiers and aviators for propaganda purposes. As I determined with many of the images used in the blog, The Night Witches (click here to read the blog), quite a few of the photos used here have been staged. I really don’t think a sniper would want a photographer hovering over them while lining up a “kill” shot. But I’ll let you be the judge of that.
Sniper Lyudmila Pavlochenko in combat at Sevastopol. Photo by anonymous (c. June 1942). Ozerksy/AFP/Getty Images.Sniper Liza Mironova in combat. Photo by anonymous (c. 1943). AFP/Getty Images.
Pavlichenko, Lyudmila. Translated by David Foreman. Lady Death: The Memoirs of Stalin’s Sniper. Yorkshire: Greenhill Books, 2018. (Originally published by Veche Publishers, Moscow, 2015).
There may be a chance that after we publish this particular blog, the video links associated with the blog are no longer accessible. We have no control over this. Many times, whoever posts the video has done so without the consent of the video’s owner. In some cases, it is likely that the content is deemed unsuitable by YouTube. We apologize if you have tried to access the link and you don’t get the expected results. Same goes for internet links.
What’s New With Sandy and Stew?
As you read this Sandy and I are sitting on an airplane on our way home from Europe. (That is, provided we can find a place in Glasgow to get a COVID test one day prior to entering the states.) Obviously, I’m writing this prior to us returning so I will have to wait several weeks for our next blog to begin talking about our adventures in Paris, London, and Glasgow.
Thank you to all of you who subscribe to our bi-weekly blogs. It seems there isn’t a day that goes by where we don’t increase our readership. Please let your history buff friends and family members know about our blog site and blogs.
Someone Is Commenting On Our Blogs
Thanks to our good friend, Greg S., for his comment on the blog, S-Bahn Serial Killer (click here to read). He rated it a “Two thumbs up!”
If there is a topic you’d like to see a blog written about, please don’t hesitate to contact me. I love hearing from you so keep those comments coming.
Mr. Ross brings the streets of Paris to life, making it possible for you to stand on the very spots where the grand and tragic events of the French Revolution took place. If you are looking for more than just the typical tourist experience in Paris, then this book is must reading!
Dan Carpenter | Historian & Author
Stewart Ross’ book is full of interesting documents and research, it put you well on the tracks of Marie Antoinette, Danton, Robespierre and many more, whether in Paris or in Versailles, extremely interesting and easy to read!
Raphaelle Crevet | Certified Tour Guide, Paris, France
